The girls decide that Mackenzie is going to try to bring dream Sabrina (whom they speculate is a wheetigo) back from her dream. Tracey and Kassidy will stay awake to watch over Mackenzie as she dreams. They play a game of cribbage while discussing their plan and agree that if Mackenzie can bring back Sabrina/wheetigo, they will kill her. After the girls finish their game, they stay up talking. They feel like little kids again, and Mackenzie is happy to be home.

Gradually, they tire, and Mackenzie falls into a deep sleep. She dreams she is back at the lake, searching for Sabrina. Snow swirls around her, and she shivers. She sees a figure ahead of her in the clearing which she assumes is Sabrina. She moves closer and realizes that it is not Sabrina but Tracey. She hears Kassidy and knows that she is also in the dream. Tracey is standing with her arms outstretched, whimpering. Mackenzie wonders if she is finally witnessing what happened that night in the woods. Suddenly, Sabrina enters the clearing. She is upset and calls out to Tracey.