Dannie and Bella meet at a favorite café to catch up after two months of not finding time to see each other. As they talk about their lives, Dannie reflects on the differences in their personalities: Dannie is regimented and careful, while Bella is artistic, creative, and more fluid in her plans and goals. Bella tells Dannie that she has a new boyfriend named Greg and that he’s different from the men she’s dated before; she likes him a lot and thinks they’re becoming serious. Dannie is wary but agrees to go on a double date with Bella and Greg in a few weeks.

On their double date, Dannie discovers that Greg is actually Aaron, the man she saw in her premonition almost five years ago. Surprised and reeling, Dannie acts strangely on the date. She asks Aaron abrupt questions and then excuses herself to the bathroom. David tells Bella and Aaron that Dannie was feeling ill earlier but didn’t wanted to miss the dinner; Bella believes this is a lie and that Dannie hates Aaron. That night, Dannie has a bad dream in which she and Bella are in the apartment from the dream.