There are differing concepts of karmic reincarnation. With a rebirth so unfavorable as the one portrayed in this story, some people would call it punishment, while others would view it more constructively as an opportunity for the narrator to learn from his past life’s mistakes. Still others would argue something different. What does Butler suggest is the purpose for the narrator’s reincarnation? Cite textual evidence.

The entire story is presented through the narrator’s eyes. What would it be like to see the marriage through the former wife’s eyes? What clues in the text suggest how she viewed their marriage? Do you think the narrator’s jealousy was warranted? What textual evidence supports your position?

Is the story more of a comedy or a tragedy? Consider the narration’s tone and the nature of the story’s ending.