Arthur McLachlan sees his life as a story. He was born in Coeur d’Alene, but the city has changed over the years. His childhood wasn’t happy, but he doesn’t blame his mother because life in Coeur d’Alene was harder then. He doubts the younger book club members fully understand. The way they interpret The Joy Luck Club and The Remains of the Day reflects their lack of understanding.

Sloane arrives and interrupts Arthur’s thoughts. He realizes how much his life has changed since he met her. He asks her about what they should read for their next book. He wants a more serious story, but Sloane doesn’t like his suggestions. She then informs him they’re going to have someone new joining their meeting today. Arthur doesn’t like that she’s turned his house into a playground, but he’s secretly grown attached to the group.

Arthur gets upset when he discovers that the visitor is Nigel Carthage. He tells Nigel that he’s never been a friend and wants him to leave. However, Arthur also knows that he’s been powerless ever since he and Greg talked about Greg’s mother, Hannah.

Nigel explains that he wants to join Arthur’s book club. Arthur doesn’t understand why but tells Nigel that they’re currently selecting their next title.