By springtime, Alice learns to read Dylan’s moods, as she used to with her abusive father. As long as she is mindful, the couple remains blissful.

One night, Dylan works late, so he’ll miss their walk. Alice tells him she’ll stay in, but she decides to walk Pip anyway. They get home late, and Dylan is rageful. He kicks Pip in the ribs and lunges at Alice. He accuses her of cheating and shakes her by the neck. Alice calls Pip, who is shivering with fear. The dog seems okay.

Dylan cries. He apologizes and says she’s the love of his life, promising that he lashed out from worry. He thinks other guys are much better and that she’ll fall in love with someone else. He’s become obsessed and possessive of her. Alice defends herself, saying that she only went for a walk, and reassures him that she loves him, no matter what. Dylan gives her a bath and tends to her bruises.

Pip is traumatized from Dylan’s attack. Alice emails Moss for help. She lies that Pip was attacked by a wild animal. Moss sends medicine for Pip’s ribs. Slowly, Pip becomes less fearful, but she clings to Alice over Dylan.