The novel moves back in time again to when Remy is a boy. Dina takes Shirin to “St. Mary’s Home for Disabled Boys” near its namesake church in Bandra (261). At the home, Sister Hillary takes Shirin and Dina to see Cyloo, who is in a wheelchair and in the middle of his daily exercises.

Shirin asks to spend a few moments with him privately. She is astonished when he smiles and waves at her and tries to say Remy’s name, and she resolves to create a similar atmosphere at home for Cyloo. However, Dina reveals that Cyrus has given up custody of Cyloo on both of their behalf. Dina also points out how Cyloo seems happy and is progressing here. A conflicted Shirin begins to sob, and Dina asks her to go home and talk things through with Cyrus.

Cyrus is waiting for Shirin at home, having learned of her visit to the home. They get into a fight that is interrupted by a scared Remy who runs into their room, begging them to stop. Cyrus and Shirin eventually strike a bargain that involves her keeping her silence in exchange for visiting Cyloo every Saturday, while Cyrus stays home with Remy.